A side effect of IF tele lenses,
or how to gain magnification with an extension tube without getting closer to the subject…
We all know that mounting an extension tube between a tele lens and the camera body we can come more closer to the subject, than allowed by the minimum focusing distance of the lens itself, thus obtaining a greater magnification. With old tele lenses, those ones that focused closer by extending with an elicoid which increased the physical length of the lens barrel, it was more or less all we could do with an extension tube.
With new tele lenses with internal focusing (IF) we have other tricks to increase magnification.
IF lenses do not extend physically when focusing closer than infinity, rather, lens group(s) are moved back and forth within the lens barrel. This renders the tele more balanced and comfortable to use, and also allows to reach a shorter minimum focusing distance (thus a greater magnification), than old tele lenses.
However, the actual focal length of IF tele lenses decreases markedly at short distances, and the difference between the nominal and the actual focal lengths can be rather great at the minimum focusing distance..
For instance, the recent Nikon and Canon 300 f4 AFS/USM (as well as the older 300 f4 Sigma Apo Macro) lenses can be focused as close as about 1,5m (the Sigma goes even closer), but at that distance their actual focal length is a mere 220-230mm. So, with an IF tele lens you gain some magnification because you can go closer to the subject, but in turn you lose some magnification due to the shortening of the focal length
HERE COMES THE EXTENSION TUBE: With an extension tube, at medium short distances you can gain more magnification even without moving closer to the subject!
Why? Simple, because by adding an extension tube, even if you do not change the distance between film/sensor and subject, you must put the focusing ring to a greater distance to have the subject in focus in order to compensate the extension. As a consequence, by focusing to a greater distance the decrease of the ACTUAL focal length will be less pronounced, so that the magnification will be GREATER than without the tube. So, by adding an extension tube to your IF tele lens you can gain magnification even without moving closer than the minimum focusing distance. Shots taken with a Nikon D200
I have taken some shots with my Nikon 300
f4AFS with aan without the Nikon PN 11 (a 5,2cm extension tube).
Nikon 300mm f4 AFS alone, subject at 2,5 m from sensor plane

Nikon 300mm f4 AFS plus PN 11 extension tube actual distance of the subject again 2,5 m (plus the 5,2cm of the tube) from sensor plane, lens focused close to infinity

Nikon 300mm f4 AFS alone, subject at 2 m from sensor plane

Nikon 300mm f4 AFS plus PN 11 extension tube, actual distance of the subject again 2 m (plus the 5,2cm of the tube) from sensor plane, lens focused at around 7,5m

Nikon 300mm f4 AFS alone, subject at minimum focusing distance (1,45m) from sensor plane

Nikon 300mm f4 AFS plus PN 11 extension tube, at minimum focusing distance (plus the 5,2cm of the tube) from sensor plane, lens focused at around 2,5m

As you can see from the shots, the gain in magnification is rather consistent, since the actual focal length remain closer to the nominal one (which is real only around infinity) .
March 12, 2007